Goodwin Law logo
Contact us
Goodwin Law Contact

DISCHARGE WITHOUT CONVICTION – DRINK DRIVING

Mar 14, 2024

BT was charged with driving with excess breath alcohol. BT was assisted by Ciara and pleaded guilty early in the proceedings and applied for a discharge without conviction. 

The incident occurred after BT made the erroneous decision to drive after celebrating her university graduation with friends, going to bed and sleeping for a number of hours before waking up early in the morning to leave the address. When stopped by Police, BT returned an alcohol-breath reading of 662 mcgs.

At sentencing Ciara outlined for the judge how BT had a difficult past which she had overcome to obtain a degree as a healthcare professional. However, the impact of a conviction would stymie the progression of her career, which was only at an early stage and BT had completed various courses to make amends for her actions.  

The application was successful and a discharge without conviction was granted. 

DISCHARGE WITHOUT CONVICTION – DRINK DRIVING

Dec 22, 2023

GJ was charged with driving with excess breath alcohol. She was assisted by Ciara, pleaded guilty early in the proceedings and applied for a discharge without conviction.

At sentencing, Ciara argued the impact of a conviction on GJ would be out of all proportion to the gravity of the offence. On the day of the incident, GJ was responding to a distressed call from a family member, was stopped by Police and returned an alcohol-breath reading of 584 mcg.

The impact of a conviction on GJ was that she and her family would lose a critical source of income. GJ had also engaged with various courses and completed community work to atone for the wrongdoing.

The matter was opposed by Police Prosecutions but GJ’s application was successful and a discharge without conviction was granted.

Media

‘Run it Straight’ death: Lawyer surprised no criminal investigations made

‘Run it Straight’ death: Lawyer surprised no criminal investigations made

May 29, 2025

Heather du Plessis-Allan from Newstalk ZB interviewed Matt Goodwin seeking his perspective on the potential for criminal liability in the death of a Palmerston North teen participating in a ‘run it straight’ game. Matt explained that the Police may have been hasty in reaching a decision not to carry out criminal investigations, especially in light of the manner of harm, but acknowledged that the Police are privy to facts that the public are not. Listen to the interview here.

FMA criticised for delayed investment scam warning after retiree loses $1m

FMA criticised for delayed investment scam warning after retiree loses $1m

Apr 1, 2025

The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) has been criticised for their delayed response in issuing scam warnings. This is in connection to the $1 million lost by the scam victim in the case handled by Matt Goodwin below, meaning that the FMA are suggested to have contributed to the success of the scam. In trial, Matt said the case should be a ‘wake up call’ for the FMA. Read full article here.

Tags